Skip to content
Fri 20 Nov 2026 Toronto Sign in
Creator Economy

Japan’s Courts Say Your Voice Is Yours. The TikTok Clone Still Got Away

A Tokyo court recognized voice as a publicity right in anime star Kenjiro Tsuda's AI-clone suit against TikTok, then dismissed his takedown demand because the uploader had already deleted the account.

A studio microphone with a pop filter in a dark recording booth
Illustration: prompt/power

Kenjiro Tsuda won the argument and lost the case. On Sept. 30, the Tokyo District Court ruled that a person’s voice can be protected under Japan’s publicity rights, the first time a Japanese court has said so, according to Music Business Worldwide, which drew on AFP’s reporting. Then it dismissed his demand that TikTok take down the videos that cloned him, because there was nothing left to take down.

Tsuda, 55, is one of anime’s most recognizable voices: Kento Nanami in Jujutsu Kaisen, Seto Kaiba in Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Monsters. His lawsuit targeted TikTok’s operator over at least 188 videos, posted between July 2024 and September 2025, that used AI-generated narration resembling his voice over clips about urban legends and conspiracy theories, The Next Web reports. The account had more than 210,000 followers and averaged 1.47 million views per video. MBW puts its estimated earnings at ¥500,000 to ¥750,000 a month, about US$3,200 to US$4,800 (roughly CA$4,450 to CA$6,700).

That is a small business. It was built on someone else’s throat.

What the judge actually said

Presiding Judge Aya Takahashi held that publicity rights can cover a voice when it is used for its commercial appeal. In AFP’s translation, as quoted by Music Business Worldwide: “The unauthorized use of a performer’s voice … can be considered an infringement on publicity rights.” Inven Global reports the court reasoned that a person’s voice, like their portrait, symbolizes an individual’s personality.

Tsuda had argued under both Japan’s Unfair Competition Prevention Act and publicity rights that the narration was meant to draw viewers by confusing them with his voice, per Inven Global. TikTok’s defence was that this was a “generic male voice” and that any resemblance was “subjective”; the platform also said the account holder claimed the voice model was “trained on a friend’s voice”.

The court never had to decide whether that was true. The anonymous uploader deleted the account while the suit was under way, so the takedown claim had no target. Tsuda’s side, according to Inven Global, said its “original objective was fully achieved” anyway.

A right without a remedy, for now

For creators, that outcome cuts two ways. The principle is now on the books: in Japan, a recognizable voice is something you can own commercially, not just a sound anyone can model. That is the hard part, and it has been decided in performers’ favour.

The enforcement problem is untouched. An anonymous account monetized a clone for more than a year, a famous performer had to sue the platform to get anywhere, and the uploader made the whole thing moot by hitting delete. A working voice actor without Tsuda’s profile, or a mid-size streamer whose voice gets cloned for a scam channel, faces the same anonymity with fewer resources.

The ruling did not arrive in a vacuum. Japan’s publicity rights are judge-made, recognized by the Supreme Court in 2012, and no statute spelled out voice protection. This summer the Justice Ministry moved first: an expert committee concluded on July 27 that voices should fall under publicity rights and that people can demand compensation or removal of posts where infringement is confirmed. The final report, published Aug. 7, was issued as an interpretive guideline, MBW reports, citing Jiji Press. It singled out AI “cover” tracks as a particular harm.

Performers have been organizing too. Japanese voice actors launched a campaign in 2024 against unauthorized AI voice cloning, The Next Web notes. Yuko Sasaki, executive director of the Japan Actors Union, has described a voice as “the result of years of rigorous training and apprenticeship”.

How it compares

In the US, protection is patchy. Tennessee’s ELVIS Act, signed in March 2024, was the first US state law to add voice to existing publicity protections. The federal NO FAKES Act would create an intellectual property right in a person’s voice and visual likeness but has drawn objections over carve-outs for satire and political commentary, MBW notes. Canada has no voice-specific statute.

Our read: Japan now has something closer to a national standard than the US does, delivered by a district court and a ministry guideline rather than a legislature. The open question for creators is whether platforms will treat it as a reason to act on voice-clone complaints before the lawsuit, not after the account vanishes.

Tsuda’s clone told stories about urban legends. The legend now has a citation: 188 videos, a deleted account, and a judgment that says the voice was his.

// How we reported this

Researched and drafted with AI tools, fact-checked against primary sources and approved by a human editor before publishing. Prices and dates are as of publication. Our standards →

Sources
  1. musicbusinessworldwide.com — according to Music Business Worldwide
  2. thenextweb.com — The Next Web reports
  3. invenglobal.com — Inven Global
  4. digitalmusicnews.com — "the result of years of rigorous training and apprenticeship"
Columnist, Creator Economy & Culture Casie Stewart

Casie Stewart covers the creator economy, social platforms and wellness tech for prompt/power: who gets paid, who gets seen, and what the algorithm is really asking of the people who feed it. She has been publishing online since 2005, long before "creator" was a job title, and has spent most of that time on the other side of the platforms she now writes about. Based in Toronto. Her rule for any new app: if it promises to save you time, check how much of it you just spent reading the onboarding.

All stories by Casie →

Latest from prompt/power

  1. How to read an IPO prospectus in 10 minutes, using Anthropic’s as the exampleNov 20
  2. ChatGPT Pro, Claude Max or Google AI Ultra? What CA$140 a month buysNov 20
  3. Anthropic’s first day, studied: who made money, what it left on the table, and what ANT is now worthNov 20
  4. Google’s Gemini health coach costs CA$12.99 a month, or nothing with AI Pro. What it does and doesn’t doNov 20
  5. Broadcom’s AI chip sales now outstrip its entire business from a year ago. What to watch on Dec. 9Nov 19

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *